Social media has become a powerful tool for hotels to engage with guests, showcase their brand, and drive bookings. However, many hoteliers still rely on vanity metrics—likes, shares, and follower counts—to measure success. While these numbers look good on reports, they don’t necessarily translate into revenue or guest loyalty. So, what should hotels focus on instead? Let’s find out today.
What Are Vanity Metrics?
Vanity metrics are surface-level statistics that may indicate popularity but don’t provide meaningful insights into business impact. These include:
- Likes and shares: Indicate awareness but don’t necessarily drive bookings.
- Follower count: A large audience is useless if they’re not engaged.
- Impressions: Seeing your post doesn’t mean someone will book a stay.
While these metrics aren’t entirely useless, they need to be analyzed in the context of deeper engagement and conversion rates.
What’s Changing?
The digital landscape is evolving, and algorithms now prioritize engagement over sheer numbers. Consumers are also more discerning, looking for authenticity and relevance rather than mass marketing. For hotels, this means shifting from vanity metrics to data that reflects real interactions, guest intent, and conversions.
For instance, algorithms on platforms like Instagram and LinkedIn now prioritize meaningful interactions over sheer volume. A hotel’s social media post that sparks in-depth discussions and guest testimonials will be ranked higher than one that simply accumulates passive likes.
Additionally, guests are increasingly looking for authentic experiences. They want real-time responses, personalized interactions, and engaging content that resonates with them on a deeper level. Hoteliers who rely solely on vanity metrics risk missing out on valuable opportunities to connect with potential guests.
The Problem With Vanity Metrics
While vanity metrics may indicate reach, they don’t reveal how social efforts drive bookings or guest satisfaction. A hotel may have thousands of followers, but if engagement doesn’t lead to inquiries or stays, the marketing effort lacks measurable value. Without deeper insights, hotels risk investing in strategies that don’t contribute to business goals.
Metrics That Truly Matter
To measure real social media impact, hotels should track metrics that indicate user engagement and business outcomes.
-
Engagement Metrics
Engagement metrics provide a clearer picture of guest interaction and sentiment. These metrics provide insight into how users interact with your content. Hotel marketers need to examine the depth of that engagement, digging deeper than likes alone and focusing on getting their audience to take meaningful action.
- Comments are the new source of feedback
Comments convey genuine emotion. Both positive and negative feedback in the form of comments highlight how captivating the content is, what’s working, and what isn’t. - Share of Voice tells how often the hotel is mentioned compared to competitors
This helps to understand which hotels customers engage with the most, and take a leaf out of their playbook to guide your content strategy - Sentiments indicate how your content makes the customer feel
It is important to understand how a customer feels about your hotel business. This can often be understood through the context of a comment. Knowing how to decipher the comment and the customer’s emotions helps hotels take meaningful action. - Direct Messages (DMs) indicate a highly engaged audience
Personalized interactions in DMs often indicate serious guest interest, whether it’s about reservations or special requests.
- Comments are the new source of feedback
-
Conversion Metrics
Conversion metrics track how social media efforts translate into tangible business outcomes.
- Click-Through Rates (CTRs) indicate how compeling the content truly is
It measures how often users click on links in posts, leading to booking pages or promotions. This indicates the customers’ motivation to take the next step, read more, learn more, or buy. - Booking conversions help determine ROI
It indicates how often does the content / messaging compel your target customer book your hotel room, or take another action such as signing up for newsletter or a loyalty program.
- Click-Through Rates (CTRs) indicate how compeling the content truly is
-
Customer Retention Metrics
The role of social media isn’t limited to building a brand reputation and attracting new customers. It also plays a pivotal role in in retaining existing ones. And with the right messaging and content on your social media channels, you can develop much deeper relationships with your audiences & customers. Two critical retention metrics that hotels must track are:
- Repeat Purchases
- Loyalty Sign-Ups
Tools And Technologies Empowering Brands
-
AI-Powered Insights
Artificial intelligence helps hotels analyze social data, predict trends, and optimize content strategies. AI tools can determine the best times to post, identify guest preferences, and generate personalized content.
-
Social Listening Tools
Social listening platforms track mentions and guest sentiment across social media. Hotels can address guest concerns in real-time, improve services, and identify new opportunities based on audience feedback.
-
Integrated Dashboards
Analytics dashboards centralize data from different platforms, offering a unified view of performance. Hotels can assess engagement, conversions, and guest behaviors in one place, leading to better decision-making.
How Can Hoteliers Act?
To effectively measure and improve social media impact, hoteliers can implement the following strategies:
-
Track Meaningful Engagement
- Monitor comments, DMs, and shares instead of just likes.
- Encourage guest-generated content and actively engage with it.
- Example: A beachfront resort creates a branded hashtag for guests to use when sharing their experiences. By interacting with these posts and resharing them, the hotel fosters deeper engagement and builds credibility.
-
Utilize Social Listening Tools
- Use platforms like Sprout Social or Brandwatch to track brand mentions and sentiment.
- Identify trends in guest feedback to refine services and marketing.
- Example: A city hotel notices frequent Twitter complaints about slow check-ins. They introduce a mobile check-in system and promote it via social media, addressing concerns proactively.
-
Measure Conversions, Not Just Awareness
- Set up trackable links (UTMs) to measure direct bookings from social campaigns.
- Monitor click-through rates (CTR) on promotional posts.
- Example: A boutique lodge runs a Facebook ad for a special weekend package. By tracking UTM links, they discover that Instagram Stories drive 3x more bookings than Facebook posts, refining their future ad strategy.
-
Enhance Guest Retention through Social Engagement
- Reward loyal guests with exclusive social media offers.
- Create personalized experiences based on past interactions.
- Example: A luxury hotel identifies repeat guests who frequently engage with their social content. They surprise these guests with a complimentary spa treatment during their next visit, strengthening brand loyalty.
-
Leverage AI for Predictive Insights
- Use AI-driven analytics to predict the best times to post and the type of content that resonates.
- Example: A resort uses AI to analyze past engagement trends and finds that sunset-themed posts get the most traction. They schedule more of this content during peak engagement times, resulting in higher interaction rates.
As the landscape of social media marketing shifts, hoteliers must move beyond vanity metrics and focus on engagement, sentiment, and conversions. By adopting a data-driven approach and leveraging the right tools, hotels can enhance guest relationships, drive bookings, and create lasting brand loyalty.
The question now is—are you ready to go beyond the numbers and truly connect with your guests?
