How to avoid overrated hotels, fake reviews, and influencer traps when Planning your stay
Jul 4, 2025
Booking a hotel was once straightforward—read a few reviews, find a deal, and you’re set. Today, though, travelers face a maze of polished Instagram posts, paid influencer content, AI-written reviews, and inflated star ratings. The result? Too often, a disappointing stay. Here are practical tips to help you navigate the noise and book smarter.
Key takeaways
- Reviews are unreliable: Guest scores and online reviews often skew unrealistically positive or are outright fake. Advice: Read a mix of 1–2 star and average reviews, focusing on aspects that matter to you—noise, cleanliness, amenities, etc. Recurring complaints deserve extra scrutiny.
- Scrutinize photos & fine print: Hotels frequently display glamorous suite photos, not the type of room you’ll actually get. Advice: Always review images of the exact room category you plan to book. Check whether amenities like coffee makers or hair dryers are included before reservation.
- Rely on seasoned critics, not influencers: Influencers often receive comped stays or get paid to post, while AI bots pump out fake reviews. Advice: Turn to respected, anonymous hotel reviewers (e.g., Michelin Guide, Rick Steves, Frommer’s, The Telegraph) for unbiased evaluations.
- Consider location & surroundings: Distance indicators on booking sites can be misleading, and surroundings may hide drawbacks. Advice: Use maps to check what’s nearby—train lines, airports, nightlife, or sketchy neighborhoods—before booking.
- Book directly with the hotel: Often, third-party sites (Expedia, Booking.com, etc.) must match prices available on the hotel’s own website due to rate parity. Advice: Booking directly can lead to better upgrades, room selection, and smoother customer service for cancellations or problems.
- Question brand consistency: Many chain hotels operate as franchises that vary widely in quality. Advice: Don’t assume consistency just because of a brand name; check each property individually.
- Use niche hotel groups: If you prefer specific styles—heritage homes, eco-lodges, boutique design—join curated networks like Historic Hotels of America, Beyond Green, or Design Hotels.
- Leverage travel agents: Travel agents can be invaluable, especially for luxury or complex bookings. Their service is usually free (commission-paid), and they may secure upgrades or perks. Advice: For upscale stays, even in smaller rooms, do not book without consulting an experienced agent.
Get the full story at The Philadelphia Inquirer (subscription required)
